I had held off writing this post because of concerns Lileks had over the authenticity of the American flag in trashcan cover of Newsweek Japan. He wrote:
I will reserve judgment on this until tomorrow, because I am sure Newsweek with clarify matters - the flag was photoshopped, the unnamed source was mistaken, America is not dead, it is merely pining for the fjords. What’s more, it’s vaguely disturbing for people to write irritated entries on their personal websites about these issues; that way lies Brownshirts and bookburning. Best you stand there and take it like a cow takes a warm, lubricated suppository.
Lyrical as ever, but even noting his warning about potential Brownshirting (Thanks, former VP Lileks- Update: He was being sarcastic- Welcome to the mob, James! Pitchforks over there!), this cover is just one itsy bitsy giant leap too far. How do I know it’s not a photoshop? Well, while the image on Riding Sun has severe image quality loss and significant artifacts, it appears to be the same graphic found on Newsweek Japan’s website.
Smaller image from Newsweek Japan’s website, larger from Riding Sun. Now, I don’t read Japanese, but the URL and site just referenced seem pretty authentic, short of some spoofing going on.
As I wrote to Jim Geraghty:
The difference is simple.
CBS was simply anti-Bush. Love guy or hate the guy, he’s just one man.
Newsweek’s article was anti-American in conception, presentation and effect.
Their factually-deficient smear was targeted at not (just) George W. Bush, but the U.S. government and the American people.
Moreover, the effects of publishing such a piece were as predictable as shouting “Fire” in a crowded theater.
As news consumers we all have a responsibility to hold media outlets’ accountable. We have been fooled twice now (that we know of!), and the shame is ours. Anyone foolish enough to continue to reward Newsweek in the marketplace is asking for more of the same lies, innuendo, and anti-American agenda.
I wrote that in the heat of the moment (before Riding Sun’s two-faced cover discovery) and hoped if it were terribly intemperate he’d delete/ignore it, with no harm done. In the cool light of reason, however, my gut feel seems to be correct. There seems to be some serious conceit at work here. (Here, in the Pepsico “scandal”, too) Newsweek, a technologically dependent, international for-profit corporation, apparently cannot fathom the fact that some of its American readers might also read Japanese and might be less than thrilled with its presentation of our country. Riding Sun’s translations:
As you can see, the cover story shows an American flag, dirtied and tossed in a trash can, its staff snapped in two. The large white text reads, “Amerika ga shinda hi”, which translates to “The day America died.” Both of the above editions featured a cover-story article by Andrew Moravcsik, titled “Dream on, America”. (This was translated into Japanese as “Yume no kuni Amerika ga kuchihateru toki”, which is even harsher; it means, roughly, “America, the dream country, is rotting away”.) According to Newsweek itself, the article described “the world’s rejection of the American way of life.”
Newsweek depends on that terrible American way of life for its own survival. Without American-invented computer networks and electronic publishing systems, not to mention the First Amendment (the basis for similar statutes in many nations worldwide), Newsweek would not exist. It would certainly not be allowed to publish Isikoff’s Koran flushing nonsense without severe governmental backlash. Just as with the “Bush = Hitler” crowd, their protests and lacrimose whining would be crushed by Big Brother’s iron boot on their throats, were America truly dead.
So, what’s truly dead? Why all the hand-wringing? It’s simple. George W. Bush is singing from their hymnal. If the left in general preach realpolitik as their way of dealing with the world, it’s not because they want that. Their ideology demands equality and freedom for all the world’s people. The extreme left is seeing the results of good-hearted conviction that the world can be made a better place through American action and resolve. Wasn’t that the real point of the 60s? To make the world a better place by your actions? George W. Bush has led the American people, through its military, to free 40 million in places no one thought democracy could thrive. And while it’s not a done deal yet, the freedom projects in Afghanistan and Iraq are looking good.
In the meantime, it is not the government’s place to punish Newsweek. It’s ours, the public’s job. Captain’s Quarters had a “Not One Dime” campaign to get the Senate to show some backbone. My suggestion is a “Not One Click, Link, or Dollar” campaign for Newsweek and its parent, the Washington Post company. I believe Matt of Blackfive is thinking along these lines. It’s time for a Newsweek boycott, including the Washington Post. Who’s with me?
Added to Outside The Beltway’s Traffic Jam